QuestionQ21

VerifiedSwitching

A German cruise-line company needs to modernize its existing fleet. To keep costs down and improve sustainability, it will refresh the ship’s internal systems, including all WLAN/LAN hardware. During this refresh, the company will retain its existing security requirements. The CIO also wants to minimize unused switch ports; any future expansion will require a hardware refresh. The work begins with the smallest ship, Ship One, which accommodates a maximum of 350 guests.

Ship One’s LAN infrastructure consists of two core switches, eight redundant distribution switches, and 200 access switches (175 cabins and 25 technical rooms).

The core switches are in the ship’s MDF, and the distribution switches are in the ship’s eight IDFs. Each cabin and each technical room has a single access switch.

The ship’s structured cabling will not be replaced. Each IDF connects to the MDF through SMF pairs. Each cabin connects to its IDF through a single MMF pair. Each technical room connects to its IDF through a single MMF pair.

For every cabin and technical room, the customer wants to replace its current fanless 2530/2540 switch without changing requirements, except that the uplink to the distribution switch must be upgraded to 10GbE to support increased network traffic.

The WLAN infrastructure will be refreshed 1:1, with no new cabling or AP locations. Its WLAN infrastructure uses 200-series indoor and outdoor APs running InstantOS (195 APs total), and the customer has no changes to WLAN requirements.

A team member currently on parental leave started the proposed solution below.

Core switch: one VSX stack of two 8325-48Y8C switches

Distribution switch: one VSF stack of two 6300F 24-port SFP+ and 4-port SFP56 switches per IDF

Cabin switch: one 6200F 12G Class4 PoE 2G/2SFP+ per cabin

Technical room switch: one 6200F 12G Class4 PoE 2G/2SFP+ per technical room

Indoor Cabin APs: AP-505H (88 total)

Indoor standard APs: AP-535 (82 total)

Outdoor APs: AP-565 (25 total)

What potential issue do you identify with the core-switch selection relative to the customer’s requirements?

Explanation

An 8325-48Y8C has 48 ports supporting 1/10/25GbE and eight 40/100GbE ports. A two-switch VSX core therefore has substantially more 1/10/25GbE ports than Ship One’s eight distribution locations require, while its 40/100GbE ports can accommodate VSX links. The 10GbE and 25GbE link speeds are supported, but the excess unused ports conflict with the stated requirement to limit unused switch ports because future expansion will instead trigger a hardware refresh.

Learn more

Community Discussion

No comments yet. Be the first to start the discussion!